Active or passive investing? The answer may be both

Bovest Admin • November 18, 2026

If you put all your investment statements on the kitchen table, it may not be so easy to find the golden thread. The unit trust you opened years ago, the retirement fund, the thing a friend recommended at a braai. Go ahead and ask yourself why you own each one.


A lot of people go quiet at that question. Investments you have made tend to pile up over the years, one decision at a time. And the way the active or passive investing debate gets talked about doesn’t help, because it sounds like a choice you have to make: pay someone to pick investments for you or simply follow the market.


Instead of choosing a side, we’re seeing a larger umbrella. Below we explain what each of these two types of investments means, and how to check that everything you own is working for you and has a good reason to be there.


What do active and passive investing mean?

A fund collects money from many investors and invests it together. The market is the overall movement of shares and other investments.

A passive fund, often called an index fund, copies a market. An index is simply a list of investments used to measure how a market is doing, and the fund holds those investments. Nobody is picking winners. When the market goes up, the fund goes up, and when it falls, so does the fund. Passive funds generally cost less.


An active fund, also called an actively managed fund, has a person or a team making the decisions. They choose what to buy and when to sell, aiming to do better than the market or to cushion you when it falls. That takes research and skill, so active funds generally cost more, and you pay the fee whether their decisions work out or not.


Is passive investing better than active?

The two types of investing are not mutually exclusive. Though fundamentally different, they can work in synergy within a broader financial strategy. Each carries its own risk: a passive fund follows the market down as well as up, and an active fund’s decisions can turn out to be wrong.


Think of a rugby team. A coach doesn’t pick fifteen players for the same position. Different players do different jobs. Investing can work in a similar way. Some investors use passive funds for some jobs and active funds for others. How much of each, if any, depends on your goals, your timeframe, how much risk you’re comfortable with and the market you’re investing in. A qualified adviser can help you work through it.


Everything you own needs a job

Your portfolio is everything you own, added together. At Bovest, we believe it should be more than a random collection of funds that happen to sit side by side. Every component should have a purpose:

  • Growth: Investments designed to build wealth over many years.
  • Income: Assets structured to pay out regular cash flow.
  • Diversification: Holdings that spread your risk so one bad market stretch doesn't affect everything at once.
  • Capital protection: Steadier assets held to safeguard money you will need in the near term.


If you struggle to explain what a specific investment is doing for you, that is worth a conversation.


Four questions worth asking

What am I trying to achieve?

Retiring at 60, school fees in eight years, buying into a business? Without a goal, an investment is a guess.


What risks am I willing and able to take?

Sitting down for a proper discussion around this question is well worth your time. It will help you determine whether passive management, active management, or a blend of both is the right fit, and exactly how much to allocate to each.


What am I paying for?

Fees aren’t a bad thing when you get something valuable for them. But you should know the total you pay for your adviser, the platform and the fund managers, and what you get in return.


How does each investment fit into the wider plan?

Not on its own, but alongside your retirement savings, tax, property, business and estate plan.


Seeing it all together

If you are looking to deepen that knowledge, there is plenty of brilliant content to explore on the Welvaartskeppers series on kykNET, where we chat with South African entrepreneurs about how they built wealth, how they look after it, and how they enjoy it. Along the way, you’ll also get real-life investment insights from industry leaders and series partners like Coronation.


“The pursuit of success is not only about financial prosperity, but also about the need to broaden your knowledge.”


In the end, the main question isn't which side of the active-versus-passive argument to join. It is whether you own investments that you understand, for reasons you can explain, so your time can go toward living your best life.


One conversation can change everything and put you on the path to creating wealth for life.


Get in touch by filling in the online form. We’ll schedule a time to chat, answer your questions, and share how you can build wealth for the life you envision.


Disclaimer: This article is intended for general informational purposes only and does not constitute formal financial advice.

By PJ Botha • November 3, 2026
In conversations with people, and increasingly in the media, I hear the same message: “Just put everything in the S&P 500. Over time, it will all balance out.” There is sound reasoning behind investing in a broad share index over several decades. But that advice can overlook something important: your investment horizon and your ability to stay invested when markets fall. Even investors with decades ahead may need some of their money much sooner. During the dot-com crash, the S&P 500 fell approximately 49% from its peak in 2000 to its low in 2002. Imagine watching an investment of 1 million fall to roughly 510,000, excluding dividends and currency movements. It is easy to say you would remain invested; experiencing it can feel very different. Even the eventual winners suffered. Amazon’s share price fell approximately 94% between December 1999 and September 2001. An investment of $100,000 would temporarily have been worth around $6,000. Amazon survived and eventually flourished, but other businesses did not: Webvan and eToys entered bankruptcy in 2001, with shareholders facing the loss of their entire investment. Recovery is possible for a broad market; it is never assured for an individual company. If you need to draw an income, fund a major expense or simply find the losses unbearable, you may be forced—or tempted—to sell before markets recover. Different markets followed different paths. While US shares struggled, the JSE All Share initially rose approximately 52% between March 2000 and May 2002, before falling around 37% by April 2003. At that low, it was approximately 4% below its March 2000 starting level, excluding dividends. South Africa provided diversification, but its market still experienced a substantial decline along the way. Bonds also played an important role. Over the three calendar years from 2000 to 2002, US 10-year Treasury bonds delivered a cumulative return of approximately 42% in dollars, while South Africa’s All Bond Index returned approximately 63% in rand, including reinvested income. These are full-period returns, rather than peak-to-trough figures, but they show how different asset classes can support a portfolio when shares struggle. The Rand added another layer. It started 2000 at approximately R6.12 to the dollar and weakened dramatically, briefly reaching around R13.85 in December 2001. It subsequently recovered, briefly revisiting roughly R6.10 in December 2003 and trading around those levels again in July 2004. Rand weakness initially cushioned offshore losses for South African investors; the subsequent strengthening worked in the opposite direction. Moving offshore after a sharp currency decline can therefore introduce its own risks. Artificial intelligence (AI) is creating exciting opportunities today. The internet boom offers a useful reminder: a technology can change the world without every investment in it delivering a good return. The price paid and the expectations built into that price still matter. This does not mean a similar crash is imminent, or that investors should avoid the S&P 500. It means that an investment can be a useful part of a portfolio without being the right place for all your money. At Bovest, we build portfolios around your goals, income needs and investment horizon. Diversification across companies, sectors, countries, currencies and asset classes cannot prevent every loss, but it can reduce dependence on one outcome. The best portfolio is one that supports your financial goals—and that you can live with when markets become uncomfortable.
November 3, 2026
Die spoed en omvang waarteen inligting en ontledings in ons moderne tyd aangebied word, is verstommend. Ons hoef nie meer ure in biblioteke te sit om navorsing te doen nie. Die internet en kunsmatige intelligensie kan ingewikkelde onderwerpe verduidelik, uiteenlopende menings saamvat en ontledings aanbied. Hierteenoor leef ons in een van die mees problematiese tydperke van die wêreldgeskiedenis – geo-politieke verhoudinge is kompleks en gespanne en Westerse lande ervaar uiteenlopende intense uitdagings. Help al die inligting en ontledings ons noodwendig om beter besluite te neem? Ek dink nie so nie. Daar is een vermoë wat die internet nie kan bied nie - dit is menslike wysheid. Die Griekse filosoof, Socrates, sê hoe slimmer ons word hoe meer besef ons hoe min ons eintlik werklik weet: “Ek weet dat ek nie weet nie”. Miskien is dit die eerste teken van wysheid om nie deurgans antwoorde te hê nie, maar om eerder beter vrae te vra. Wysheid is nie om alles te weet nie, maar om te weet wat werklik saak maak. Dan kom ons weer terug by die kernvraag wat ons deesdae moet vra: “Maak die beskikbaarheid van kennis ons noodwendig wyser.” Nie noodwendig nie. Kennis gee vir ons feite en ontledings; wysheid vra egter meer. Dit vra besinning, oordeel, perspektief, selfkennis uit ervaring, en die vermoë om te onderskei tussen wat ons kan doen en wat ons behoort te doen. ‘n Mens kan boeke oor verlies lees, maar die dood van ‘n geliefde leer jou iets wat geen ontleding volledig kan oordra nie. Daar is ook ‘n oënskynlike verband tussen ouderdom en wysheid Ouderdom waarborg nie noodwendig wysheid nie. Sommige mense word oud sonder om besinnende vrae te vra en sonder om ooit uit hul foute te leer. Ervaring, daarteenoor, wat gekoppel is aan nadenke en selfondersoek, bring ‘n soort insig wat nie bloot uit die versameling van feite ontstaan nie. In die Bybelse boek, Spreuke, word wysheid in ‘n groter morele raamwerk geplaas. Kennis behoort met nederigheid, insig en verantwoordelike vermeng te word. Miskien is dit die paradoks van ons tyd: ons beskik oor al hoe meer antwoorde, maar die belangrikste vrae bly op ‘n menslike vlak. Wat is reg? Wat is genoeg? Wanneer moet ek swyg? Hierdie vrae vra meer as inligting. Hulle vra lewenservaring en insig. Die uitdaging van ons tyd is dus nie om meer kennis te versamel nie, maar om te leer hoe om dit wys te gebruik. Want kennis kan ons help om die wêreld te verander. Wysheid help jou om te besluit watter verandering die moeite werd is. Die kern van ons samelewinguitdagings in die tydperk waarin ons lewe is in werklikheid ‘n spanning tussen ons tegnologiese vermoëns en ons menslike vermoë om sinvol te oordeel. Ons het vandag dalk beter instrumente as ooit tevore, maar dit beteken nie dat ons noodwendig beter besluite neem, meer begrip vir mekaar het of gelukkiger saamleef nie. Hoe meer ek van die lewe leer, hoe minder klink absolute sekerheid na wysheid. Geskryf deur Koos van die Waterberge vir Bovest